It's not easy writing a review of this anime. For one thing, it's more
allegorical than the Narnia books, forcing the viewer to think really hard
about what the hell just happened on screen. And as if that wasn't
difficult enough, the director of this movie enjoys muddying the waters by
explaining things like the Deep Meaning behind the climax by saying he
simply wanted to see pretty girls transform into cars. Yeah, thanks for
clearing that up.
But it's patently obvious even to a blockhead like me (and despite the red
herrings from the director) that Revolutionary Girl Utena: the Movie is
all about growing up and escaping from the shackles society and our own lives
try to place on us. Pink-haired yet tomboyish Utena Tenjou, trying to run away
from a deeply troubled past, finds herself at an exclusive private academy.
Utena's fellow students, though, are just as fractured psychologically as she
is. Some are wracked with guilt, some are blinded by passion, some are dominated
by their own lack of self-esteem, and at least one has been turned into a cow
(hey, don't ask me, okay?). Several of these troubled students try to exorcise
their demons, both internal and external, through duels - sharp, often brutal
battles with swords.
Utena, at first isolated from the world and people around her by her own
preoccupation with her inner torment, finds her barriers being broken down
by two things. The first is the aforementioned duels; Utena holds a
strange fascination for the duellists already at the academy, and discovers
during the course of them that she holds a power within her that threatens
the noxious status quo of the academy, which keeps all the students walled
away from each other inside their own pain. The second is her friendship
with (and growing romantic attachment to) fellow student Anthy Himemiya, a
purple-haired East Indian girl of nearly ethereal beauty. As events
progress, both Utena and Anthy realize that the wounds on their respective
souls cannot heal unless they escape the oppressive atmosphere of the
academy, but they also realize that neither can do it alone.
Naturally, given what I said at the start about the massively allegorical nature
of this movie, things aren't laid out quite that simply or straightforwardly,
and they definitely don't proceed that way! It seems as though every second
of Utena: the Movie's footage is laden with iconic symbolism and dramatic
metaphor. The animation is lush, sprinkled with things like drowning memories,
butterflies that transform into bedsheet-winged fairies, swirling rose petals
kicked up during intense duels in an entire field of roses, baroque architecture
that moves with a mind of its own, the academy itself as a black monstrosity
on wheels, and, of course, girls turning into cars. Characterization, plot,
and animation meld seamlessly into a dreamlike fable about Utena and Anthy's
attempt to get away from what the academy represents.
Even though the movie is based on the events of the 39-episode TV series, the
storyline is so condensed and so poetic that even watching the TV series won't
help much with understanding the movie. The characters and some plot elements
are the same, yes... but the ultimate focus of the story is very different.
Despite being more allegorical than the TV series, the movie is also much more
raw, emotionally. The extended climax with the cars, for all its nigh-impenetrable
imagery, practically crackles with tension and the desire of our heroines to
attain emotional freedom. The combination of visual poetry and deep symbolism
will cause you to alternate between a stoned fascination for the stunning images
on screen, and a mindbending focus on just what the hell this all MEANS.
However, despite the lushness of the animation and the attractive draw of the
symbolism, not everything about Utena: the Movie is... well, roses. While
you can definitely sit and veg in front of this movie, oohing and aaahing over
the fantastic visuals, the natural impulse of any well-adjusted DVD-watching
human being is to try and make some sort of logical sense out of what's being
splayed across your screen. And you can't really DO that with this movie. The
utter obtuseness of the allegory sometimes can get very frustrating. Plus, the
dub is really... um... not that good. Even if it DOES feature Rachel "Misty
and Jessie from Pokemon" Lillis reprising her role as Utena. And, while
I'm listing bad points here, I was disappointed with the so-called "director's
commentary" on the DVD. Maybe we can get CPM for false advertising on that
one.
With its beautifully-rendered animation, its lesbian overtones, and its heavy
use of roses, pink, handsome guys, and romantic tragedy, Utena: the Movie
is pretty much aimed at female anime fans. But the often dark symbolism, the
intense sword duels, and the freaky-deaky car chase scene (and, of course, the
lesbians), there's plenty here for male fans to tab on to as well. If you're
looking for something different, something unique, something mind-blowingly
strange and eye-catchingly intense, and something really pink, then Utena:
the Movie's definitely up your alley.