home : news : reviews : features : fiction : podcast : blogs : t-shirts : wtf?
 

Comics Wrap-Up : Moving Pictures, The Playwright, BB Wolf and the Three LPs
Reviewed by Sarah Arnold, © 2011

Format: Comics
By:   Kathryn & Stuart Immonen, Eddie Campbell and Nate Neal, JD Arnold
Genre:   Comics
Review Date:   January 10, 2011

Every few weeks I get a new shipment of review books on my doorstep. Of course, some of these books are good and some are bad, no publishing company is perfect. My goal with this monthly/ bi-monthly wrap-up article is to give you a heads up on what might be worth buying and what to pick up at the local store, slam to the ground and yell FOR SHAME at while everyone watches.

Moving Pictures

Kathryn and Stuart Immonen, Top Shelf

Sometimes it’s hard to work with your significant other, some times it’s necessary for you both to make great art. The Immonens are in the second category.

If you have a family member or friend that enjoys art history, World War II, or not so classic love stories I would say this is a great gift book. It’s a little under 150 pages of beautiful black and white panels, telling the love story of a junior curator and a Nazi Military Art Commission officer. The Immonens also do a lovely job of recreating some famous works of art which can often be a difficult task since they are so recognizable.

This is not a feel-good story by any means, but that doesn’t always negate a pleasurable story.

The Playwright

By Eddie Campbell and Daren White, Top Shelf

There’s a reason why it came in #8 on Mr. Mark Williams' best of 2010 list. This is a rare comic book that unashamedly shows us real people and is a perfect example of a book you can throw in someone's face when they say comics are not serious literature.

Campbell is the larger drawing (excuse my pun) name, for his credits as artist on From Hell with Alan Moore. But the backbone to this book, as with most, is the story by White. The two work together beautifully, Campbell giving light to the insecurity and pubescent thoughts of the playwright with his water colors.

BB Wolf and the Three LPs

JD Arnold and Richard Koslowski, Top Shelf

Like The Playwright, this is another writer / artist paring that is very close to perfect. I know many of us are tired of the fairy-tale re-tellings. But this one is still able to pull off the idea as fresh and interesting.

It’s not, I repeat, not a book to buy your young child or sensitive mother. This is a very violent and cynical re-telling of the story set in the deep south.

As with all Top Shelf books, it has a beautiful layout and cover art. I hear that there’s a companion CD out there to listen to alongside the book, which I can only imagine gets up even deeper in the dark blues setting. I highly recommend this book if you enjoy Fables.

Sanctuary

Nate Neal, Fantagraphics

I really, really wanted to like this book. The art is well done for an emerging artist. But by the end, I strongly recommend that Neal sticks to the art side of comics and not the writing. For someone who once ran a comic anthology, I hoped Mr. Neal would’ve produced a better story.

Reading his bio in the back, the stereotype of the Brooklyn hipster jumps to mind and puts a bad taste in my mouth.

The story at first is intriguing. I love that we get a few words of gibberish to go off as dialogue and actions are the true telling of the story. It almost has a Shakespearean feel with the three old wise women who are sages for the small community and the feud between the old ruler and the younger.

But then he jumps the freaking shark. And in the most horrible of horrible ways. The three sages which have been directing the community as they see fit? They’re ALIENS! One of the most over-used tropes in all of comics comes and hits us in the face in the last five pages.

All of the wonderful characterization and plot is now ruined. This is one to yell at in the store.


RevolutionSF comics editor Sarah Arnold lives in Austin, Texas. When she isn't yelling at comic books, her other steady gig is resident nerd blogger for Do512.com.



Comments

Name:
Comments:
What number appears here?  

Nate is referring to his initial comments about Sarah's reviews and my ensuing blog about it. http://www.revolutionsf.com/bb/weblog_entry.php?e=2776
-- Rick Klaw, 10:04 AM, January 15, 2011

P.S. And what the hell is the big idea of giving away the ending of the book in a review (with no spoiler alert) anyway? Real classy, folks.
-- Nate Neal, 1:39 AM, January 15, 2011

I attempted to post the following message as a reply to the post featuring the letter I sent to Sarah Arnold, but I received an "invalid code" message--so here it is, do what you want with it (which is what you would most likely do anyway): I'm taking a stand here. I don't care what I "look like," and I'll behave anyway I please. That was a private letter to the person who wrote that brief review anyway, but good on you for posting it(whoever you are). Yeah, I was pissed off, but I stand behind everything I said. If you can dish out bland, harsh criticisms why can't you take some criticisms on your criticisms? There's no universal rule that I can't criticize a critic. Toughen up. Listen, the point I was trying to make is that if you're going to write so-called criticism--make it detailed. Make it deconstructive--or make it constructive. Don't just convey your sensations in a blurb. Serve a purpose as a critic other than parasite. Sorry I didn't sugarcoat my message. Maybe you'll think twice next time before fucking with someone's book without a detailed explanation. And in response to your quote about "doing the work," I do the work. That's why I am a professional artist. Not because I'm polite about half-assed comments about my book.
-- Nate Neal, 1:36 AM, January 15, 2011



 
Recommend Us
  • Send to a Friend
  • Digg This
  • Reddit It
  • Add to del.ic.ious
  • Share at Facebook
  • Discuss!
  • Send Feedback
  • The End is Here!
  • Golf - Beginner Fundamentals Iii: The Long Game
  • How players can prevent sun damage with their skin
  • Comics Forum
  • Related Pages
  • Print This Page
  • Top Shelf Roundup: Liar`s Kiss, Chester 5000, Lucille, Any Empire
  • Comics Screed : Items!
  • Hey, Wait
  • Search RevSF
  • New on RevSF
  • Trailer Probe: Dracula
  • RevSF Home

  •  

    Things to Buy
    Yes, YOU can get more from the brains behind RevSF.


    Your very own sweaty black RevolutionSF T-shirt!
     
    RevolutionSF RSS Feed
     
    Search RevSF


    Random RevSF
    Queen of Outer Space

     
     
     
    contact : advertising : submissions : legal : privacy
    RevolutionSF is ™ and © Revolution Web Development, Inc., except as noted.
    Intended for readers age 18 and above.