At first glance, the DVD release of The Phoenix and the
Carpet might appear to be a blatant attempt to cash in on
Harry Potter and Narnia mania by dumping a similarly
kid-themed fantasy onto the home entertainment market. How else
to explain Miramax's johnny-come-lately release of this 1997
British television miniseries? Fortunately, the effort, directed
by Michael Kerrigan and based upon the E. Nesbit novel of the
same name, isn't drek. Although wildly uneven in places, it
often manages to be downright charming.
Four adolescent siblings in Edwardian England manage to hatch
— in the fireplace, naturally enough — the egg of a Phoenix.
The Phoenix, portrayed by an animatronic muppet and voiced by
David Suchet, is wonderfully self-absorbed and vain, and wastes
no time informing the children how important and magical he
is. He also observes in passing that the new carpet the children's
parents have bought for the nursery is of the magical variety,
able to grant three wishes per day. The children, to their credit,
quickly come to an understanding of the Phoenix's prickly nature
and use that to their advantage, flattering and praising him
so that he reveals the secrets of the carpet and other mystical
excitement. Adventure, as it so often does in these situations,
ensues.
As to be expected with a miniseries, the story tends to be
episodic in nature. In their first outing the children manage
to burn through the carpet's three wishes within five minutes
of lift-off, and find themselves trapped at the bottom of a
ruined medieval tower (one which should be familiar to anyone
who's seen the George Peppard World War I epic The Blue Max).
Later, the children manage to get the Phoenix stolen by a gang
of Oliver Twist-style urchins, who pawn the bird off at an exotic
pet store.
On the rare occasion where their plans do manage to come off
relatively hitch-free, the kids wind up on a south-seas island
populated by black natives as stereotypical as any found in
turn-of-the-century literature. We're talking bone-through-the-nose,
unga bunga, throw-the-white-folk-into-the-dinner-pot natives
here. Thankfully the ensuing years have dulled the impact of
the stereotypes, and results aren't as offensively racist as
they might be. Still, no sane observer in modern America (and
modern Britain, one would hope) can watch these bizarre and
absurd scenes and not help but wonder, "What were they thinking?"
Sometimes faithfulness to the source material is not all that
it's cracked up to be.
Fortunately, The Phoenix and the Carpet has relatively
few missteps overall. The occasional cameos by the trollish
magical muppet called the Psammead are delightfully strange,
and the Phoenix's effort to experience British culture by visiting
the theatre is disastrous in all the right ways. That the children
are portrayed as real children — that is, greedy, squabbling
and immature as often as they are caring, responsible and earnest
— prevents the story from veering too far into saccharine
territory. Supposedly, E. Nesbit didn't like children all that
much, and wrote about them rather than for them. If that's the
case, then the filmmakers channeled just enough of that cynicism
to make the story more than tolerable for adult and kid alike.
DVDetails
What details? This is, without a doubt, one of the skimpiest
DVDs ever produced, underlining the fact that Miramax was only
out to make a quick buck in the family-fantasy genre. How bargain-basement
is this disc? For starters, there isn't even a paper insert
in the DVD case listing the chapter titles. On the disc itself,
a trailer for Chicken Little is included as a special
feature, and folks, if you've seen that computer animated mish-mash
of pop-culture jokes in the theater, you'll know there's nothing
special about it whatsoever.
Add to that other so-called "Special Features" such as closed
captioning and chapter select, and you've got some of the most
uninspiring extras ever assembled. Would a brief documentary
or simple listing of E. Nesbit and her work be so hard to put
together? Apparently so. That effort will have to wait for one
of the other adaptations of The Phoenix and the Carpet
to come to DVD. But I wouldn't hold my breath.
The Movie Itself: 6 out of 10
The DVD Features: 1 out of 10