home : news : reviews : features : fiction : podcast : blogs : t-shirts : wtf?

The Incredibles 2-Disc Collector's Edition
Reviewed by Andrew Kozma, © 2005

Format: Movie
By:   Brad Bird (director)
Genre:   Animated Superhero Action
Released:   March 15, 2005
Review Date:   March 15, 2005
Audience Rating:   Rated PG
RevSF Rating:   9/10 (What Is This?)

Well, yes, The Incredibles is incredible. Amazing, even, but Spider-Man sadly took that title away. But I suppose when you’re entering into a world where the labels Amazing, Fantastic, Astounding, Uncanny, Extracurricular, and Superimposed are all taken, you settle for what’s left. Or you steal your moniker from the Hulk. Luckily, he’s pretty much incoherent, and every time he sues somebody he gets found in contempt of court.

That means that we (by which I mean you, you lucky viewers, you) get a super — um, I mean amazing — er, great film that has an allusive name for all superhero lovers as well as a snappy symbol for costumes (and tattoos).

Still, you know all this. If you don’t, make sure to check out the RevSF review of the movie by Jayme Lynn Blaschke. I agree with everything he said, except that I give the movie itself a higher rating. And that means I win.


What I’m reviewing here is The Incredibles 2-Disc Collector’s Edition, and after viewing it I’m not sure why you’d want any other edition. The movie is the same, and still worth watching multiple times, as I had to do for this review (is it the pleasure of watching beautiful animation that makes repeated viewings as enjoyable as, and sometimes more so than, the first?), but there’s so much in the extras that are simply fun to watch.

It’s as though the people making the DVD had fun with it, if you can believe that. Rather than by-the-numbers extras (Making of? Check. Deleted scenes? Check. Dolby digital sound? Check. Widescreen? Che — Hey, when is sound a feature?) what we get on these two discs is the fun, joy, and excitement of the movie-making process itself. Okay, and a little of the frustration.

So, for the low, low price of whatever the company is charging you get the following:

The movie. Yep. The movie.

Two commentaries. One has Brad Bird, the writer-director, and John Walker, the producer, duking it out with words. There’s no fighting, but there’s pretty interesting discussion of all aspects of the movie. It’s slow, however, and it’s easier to watch if you’ve watched all the other extras. The second commentary features a number of animators riffing on the movie from the physical creators’ perspective. Both are good enough, especially in terms of details for each scene, but the amount of information conveyed is greater and more focused in all the documentary-style extras.

A new animated short. On the second disk there is over two hours of material for you to wade through, the first being Jack-Jack Attack. Not so amazing as a cartoon on its own, it’s a fun detailing of what happened to Kari, the babysitter, as she was taking care of Jack-Jack. Drink every time she phones Helen.

Deleted scenes. Here you see an alternate opening as well as a number of scenes taken out from the final cut. This section is great for two reasons: First, Brad Bird's explanation of why each scene was cut; second, the style that the scenes are shown in. Because animation costs a lot of money, what animators do to see how a scene works before it’s fully produced is create an animated storyboard. This technique is awesome. I’d watch an entire movie of animated storyboards — the mix of the 2-D with the 3-D is hypnotic.

Making-of documentaries. There is the general Making of The Incredibles, as well as 40 minutes of smaller sections that each focus on an individual aspect of production, such as story, software tools, and lighting. The piece gives a good look at how it would be to work at Pixar without entirely sugar-coating the process. Brad Bird comes off as a driven director — everyone seems to love him but finds him hard to deal with directly. It’s obvious that his pushing and refusal to compromise are what honed the film. Not that he’s the star, here: These featurettes make it clear how many talented people were involved in constructing the film.

Bloopers and outtakes. This was the most disappointing feature. I suppose I was expecting something akin to the end of a Jackie Chan film (as has been done in other animated features) but this is mostly a very short collection of technical errors on the way towards perfecting the software. Scenes shown in the featurettes are more amusing.

Vowellet. This is one of two small documentaries pretty much only tangentially related to The Incredibles. National Public Radio correspondent Sarah Vowell wrote this video-essay about her experience as the voice of Violet Parr, but the essay itself isn’t that simple. As a writer of essays and thought pieces, Vowell makes her interaction with the movie a reflection of her life as a whole and a comment on how presentation reflects reality.

Mr. Incredible & Pals. An old-style cartoon based on Mr. Incredible and Frozone that was okayed before heroes were forced to go underground, it stands as one of my favorite extras on the disc. It is something created only to flesh out the world. The animation is also dead-on for older cheap-o styles.

Commentary for Mr. Incredible & Pals. Mr. Incredible and Frozone themselves sit down to let us know what they think of the cartoon. Social commentary at its finest.

Hero profiles. This, along with the last two selections, is in a section of the DVD titled Top Secret, and it’s easily my favorite part of the DVDs. Ever wonder about all the other heroes that only get glimmers of screen time? Dynaguy? Thunderhead? Blazestone? Here you can find out all their stats as well as, for most of them, a voice file that really fleshes them out. Very, very nice. My only issue is that some of the heroes weren’t given voice files, which seems a copout. Sure, this is an extra for the film, but it’s sad to go so far in adding material and then pull short before finishing.

Boundin’. The short played before The Incredibles in the theater. It’s cute, fun and well-animated.

Commentary for Boundin’. Interesting and cool, almost more so for me than the cartoon.

Who is Bud Luckey? A featurette talking about Bud Luckey, the originator and main creator behind Boundin’, who also is an animator for Pixar. This is pretty interesting. Still, it’s no Top Secret.

Easter Eggs. Let me tell you about Easter Eggs. The second DVD is chock full of them (only one on the first that I could find, but it’s fun) and they aren’t difficult to find. For those of you who enjoy finding out where they are, don’t read the rest of this paragraph: A symbol (usually it’s the omnidroid, though once it was Bob) will appear near the end of a sound loop on a menu screen — just select the symbol and let it run.

I don’t usually have the patience to do the long hard search for hidden extras, but here it was easy, as though the crew at Pixar wanted you to find them. Which is a good thing. Where else are you going to find a sock-puppet rendition of the entire movie? An homage to doors and buttons? The reason Dash’s teacher deserves what he gets?

I don’t really collect DVDs, and if I did collect them I definitely wouldn’t be a collector of DVD special editions. But I'm glad to own this. It’s just cool. It’s so much more than the movie itself, which is already amazing — incredible — enough.

The Incredibles DVD Extras: 9/10
The Movie Itself: 10/10

RevSF Assistant Film Editor Andrew Kozma used to have an amazing, astounding, and incredible power. After he popped it, he realized it was only a pimple.

Recommend Us
  • Send to a Friend
  • Digg This
  • Reddit It
  • Add to del.ic.ious
  • Share at Facebook
  • Discuss!
  • Send Feedback
  • Brave
  • Cars
  • John Lasseter's winery
  • Movie Forum
  • Related Pages
  • Print This Page
  • Ratatouille: DVDetails
  • Cars
  • Sky High: DVDetails
  • Search RevSF
  • New on RevSF
  • Star Wars: The Last Jedi
  • Book Probe: BattleMaster, Wade of Aquitaine, Kriendria of Amorium
  • RevSF Podcast: Drowning in Moonlight: Remembering Carrie Fisher
  • Logan
  • RevSF Home


    Things From Our Brains
    Get even more out of RevSF.

    James Bond:
    The History of the Illustrated 007
    RevolutionSF RSS Feed
    Search RevSF

    Random RevSF
    Geek Gift Guide: Mother's Day

    contact : advertising : submissions : legal : privacy
    RevolutionSF is ™ and © Revolution Web Development, Inc., except as noted.
    Intended for readers age 18 and above.