|
LXG: League of Extraordinary Gentlemen: The Movie
Reviewed by Jess Nevins, © 2003
| Format: |
 |
Movie |
| By: |
|
Director: Stephen Norrington, Writer: James Robinson
|
| Genre: |
|
Sci-fi adventure |
| Released: |
|
2003 |
| Review Date: |
|
July 12, 2003 |
| Audience Rating: |
|
PG-13 |
| RevSF Rating: |
|
5/10 (What Is This?)
|
On the "Armageddon" to "L'Atalante" scale of films, with "Armageddon" representing
soulless, black hearted cynical manipulation and "L'Atalante" representing sublime
emotional power, "LXG" lands somewhere in the middle, as a mildly entertaining
and moderately agreeable way to waste two hours.
The mistake made by too many fans of "League," the comic book series, is to think
of this as the film adaptation of the comic book. It's not, and in fact has only
superficial elements in common with the comic. Think of "LXG" as a film which
coincidentally has most of the same characters and title as comic, and you'll
be able to enjoy it more.
"LXG," as might be expected, looks wonderful. The costuming is very nice, the
special effects are efficiently done (aside from the badly directed Hyde transformation
scenes), the Nautilus is lovely, and the scenes are properly dank and gloomy.
The action sequences are equally good; Norrington shone at those in "Blade" and
is equally adept with them here. And there are a few entertaining Easter Eggs
in the film, from a briefly glimpsed poster taken straight from the comic book
to brief literary allusions.
Unfortunately, the visuals are the high point of the film. The acting is only
intermittently good. Sean Connery as Alan Quatermain proves yet again that, in
the immortal words of Alan Swann, "he's not an actor, he's a movie star." Naseeruddin
Shah, usually an excellent actor, does a decent job with Captain Nemo's quite
uninspired lines.
Peta Wilson at least conveys the impression that Mina Harker is a real character,
which is more than can be said for Shane West, whose job as Tom Sawyer could have
been done equally as well by any number of other pretty boy actors. Tony Curran
(the Invisible Man), Stuart Townsend (Dorian Gray), and Jason Flemyng (Dr. Jekyll)
do the best at breathing life into their characters, but like Shah have lackluster
material to work with.
That is, in fact, the main problem with "LXG": the script. James Robinson's comic
book work is usually splendid, but it's clear that his talent does not extend
to the screen.
"LXG" shows a sadly predictable over-reliance on unimaginative one-liners, cliched
and stilted dialogue, lines written to get cheap and obvious laughs, and generally
unimpressively ordinary conversation. There are some amusing moments, but too
many of the "funny lines" are obvious attempts at getting laughs.
The main characters (and their nemesis) have occasionally impressive pieces of
bravado, but too often lines meant to be impressive or clever are lumbering and
trite in the Schwarzenegger manner. Too much of the dialogue is simultaneously
explanatory and boring; the former is forgivable, the latter is not. Characterization
scenes are written perfunctorily and by the numbers; characters change heart in
quite unconvincing fashion; and the film in general gives the impression of being
constructed around and for the action sequences.
"LXG" is not a horrible film, and not the fiasco I feared. I was not bored while
watching it. But there is a huge distance between "not bored" and "thrilled,"
and "LXG" does nothing to cross that distance.

|
Things to Buy
Yes, YOU can get more from the brains behind RevSF.
Your very own sweaty black RevolutionSF T-shirt! |
|
|
|
| |
|
|
| |
|
|
|